Many Western airlines are reducing or ending their connections to China. Why is this happening now and what does it mean for the future?
If you would like to book a trip or apply for a new credit card, please click here. Both support LiveAndLetsFly.com.
If you don’t already follow us on Facebook or Instagram, add us today.
Foreign airlines withdraw from China
In recent years, the global aviation industry has seen a significant withdrawal of foreign airlines from the Chinese market. During the COVID pandemic, travel restrictions (to both mainland China and Hong Kong and Macau) made leisure travel difficult if possible, although for a long time it was almost impossible.
Demand has been further reduced by a complex mix of geopolitical tensions, economic factors and evolving market dynamics. Western airlines such as British Airways, Virgin Atlantic and Qantas have either suspended or reduced their operations in China. Meanwhile, China Airlines and its competitors are seizing the opportunity to expand their international presence and reshape the landscape of global aviation.
Geopolitical tensions and the closure of Russian airspace
One of the most decisive factors contributing to the withdrawal of foreign airlines from China is the geopolitical consequences of the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022. In response to sanctions imposed by Western states, Russia has banned airlines from these countries from using its airspace. This ban has forced European and North American airlines to choose longer and more expensive routes to China, significantly affecting the profitability of these flights. British Airways, for example, announced that it would suspend its London-Beijing route for a year from the end of October 2024, citing the higher costs and longer flight times due to the need to bypass Russian airspace. In the past, British Airways called the Beijing route one of its most important.
Virgin Atlantic has also decided to suspend its London-Shanghai service indefinitely, citing the increased complexities and costs associated with avoiding Russian airspace. These operational challenges have made it difficult for Western carriers to compete with Chinese airlines, which continue to benefit from access to shorter, more direct routes via Russia.
At the beginning of the Ukraine conflict, Finnair, which focused on connecting North American and European cities with the Far East, had to change its model to take into account the impossibility of crossing Russian airspace.
“The airline launched the first non-stop flight from Western Europe to East Asia in 1983. At that time, it was not permitted to use Soviet airspace, but due to Helsinki’s location in the far northeast of Europe, a modified DC-10-30ER with additional fuel tanks was able to reach Tokyo in 13 hours via the North Pole.
A great advantage at a time when almost all passenger flights from Europe and North America to Japan had to make a refueling stop in Anchorage, Alaska. This extended the travel time to 16 hours.
In 1994, Finnair was able to enter Russian airspace just a few minutes east of Helsinki and reach Tokyo via this shortcut in just about nine hours.” – Airline Ratings
Without such a shortcut, Finnair lost its advantage.
Weaker demand and rising costs
In addition to geopolitical issues, economic factors have also played a significant role in the withdrawal of foreign airlines from China. Demand for international travel to and from China has remained weak following the pandemic, especially among Western airlines. Qantas, Australia’s national carrier, has suspended its Sydney-Shanghai flights in July 2024. citing half-empty aircraft and low demandThe slower-than-expected recovery in travel demand between China and other regions such as Australia has been a major obstacle for airlines considering resuming or expanding their China routes. .
In addition, the economic slowdown in China has dampened consumer confidence, which in turn is weakening demand for international travel. The Chinese economy, which had been expected to rebound strongly after COVID-19 restrictions were lifted, has instead faced headwinds, leading to a greater focus on domestic travel over international destinations.
Chinese airlines expand their global presence
While foreign carriers are pulling back, Chinese airlines are aggressively expanding their international operations. Chinese carriers such as China Southern, China Eastern and Air China have restored almost 90% of their international flight capacity to pre-pandemic levels. This expansion is partly due to the cost advantages these airlines enjoy, as well as their ability to operate more efficient routes over Russian airspace.
Chinese airlines also benefit from strong government support and a strategic focus on foreign exchange earnings from international flights. As domestic competition increases and profitability comes under pressure, these airlines view international markets as a key area for growth. The ability of Chinese airlines to maintain and even increase their international market share underscores the changing dynamics in global aviation, where Chinese airlines are becoming increasingly dominant. .
The future of international aviation in China
As the global aviation industry evolves, the future of international flights to and from China remains uncertain. While Chinese airlines are likely to continue their expansion, the withdrawal of foreign airlines could lead to a more closed aviation market in China, with fewer options for international travelers. This could have far-reaching consequences for global connectivity and the competitiveness of the Chinese market in the long term.
The introduction of Chinese airlines to replace Western carriers could face headwinds, with some travelers opting for shorter flight times and more frequent flights rather than European and North American airlines they have flown with in the past.
Foreign airlines may in future focus on other regions where they can operate more efficiently and profitably. The valuable take-off and landing times at major airports such as London Heathrow being reallocated from China routes to other destinations reflects this strategic shift.
Airlines have fought hard to enter the Chinese market, but now they seem neither willing nor able to return or offer full services. An impending global economic slowdown (in China it has been underway for some time) will not help Western airlines return to China. But the most pressing question is how much ground will they give up to Chinese airlines and for how long? Business customers who need expedited service to China will not wait days to adjust their schedules to British Airways’ four-times-a-week service, and leisure travelers may delay their return for some time. How many of the customers Chinese airlines poach from the business world will stay with them when other options are available? I suspect it will be fewer than Chinese airlines think.
Diploma
The withdrawal of foreign airlines from China is a multifaceted issue caused by a combination of geopolitical tensions, economic challenges and strategic considerations. As Chinese airlines continue to expand their global presence, the global aviation landscape is undergoing a profound change that has long-term implications for international travel and global connectivity.
What do you think?
